Supreme Court of South Australia overturns exploration drilling approval reinforcing the significance of Aboriginal cultural heritage issues

By Melanie Debenham, Naomi Hutchings and Nigel Amigh

A recent decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia has reinforced the significance of Aboriginal cultural heritage issues in the process of obtaining approvals for mining and exploration activities. In Dare, Bilney & Ors v Kelaray Pty Ltd, Premier of South Australia [2022] SASC 91 (Dare v Kelaray), Chief Justice Kourakis set aside the authorisation granted by the Minister (former Premier Steven Marshall), pursuant to section 23 of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA) (the Act) which was a requirement for Kelaray Pty Ltd (Kelaray) to commence drilling at the Lake Torrens exploration site.   Continue reading

A methodology for the calculation of native title compensation

 On 13 March 2019, the High Court handed down its first decision on native title compensation in ‘Timber Creek’ [2019] HCA 7 (Timber Creek).

The High Court’s decision is a measured reflection of the need for Australian law to evolve in a manner that acknowledges, recognises and accommodates the diversity and individuality of native title in Australia. The majority judgment sensibly navigates the difficult task of applying common law legal concepts, such as compensation, freehold value, economic loss and solatium, in the context of traditional rights and interests, and connection to country.

Resisting the temptation to apply a blanket approach, a 5:2 majority of the High Court instead affirmed a methodology to determine the appropriate, just and fair compensation to be awarded to native title holders for the impact of compensable acts on their distinct native title rights and interests.

Applying the methodology, the High Court determined that compensation should be paid for the extinguishment of the claim group’s non-exclusive native title rights and interests as follows:

https://www.herbertsmithfreehills.com/latest-thinking/a-methodology-for-the-calculation-of-native-title-compensation