Tag Archives: state immunity

English Court rejects Ukraine’s attempt to set aside enforcement order on grounds of state immunity

The English Court (the “Court“) has dismissed an application by Ukraine to set aside a court order permitting Russian investor, PAO Tatneft, to enforce an arbitral award against Ukraine.  Ukraine argued that it was immune from the Court’s jurisdiction by … Continue reading

Leave a Comment

Filed under Abuse of process, Arbitration Proceedings, Award, Enforcement, Europe, Immunity, Investment Arbitration, ISDS, MFN, Oil & Gas, Privileges and immunities, Sovereign Immunity/State Immunity, Ukraine

State immunity: English court considers service of proceedings on a State in times of political unrest, and questions relating to enforcement of a foreign judgment against a State

In the recent decision of Certain Underwriters At Lloyds London v Syrian Arab Republic & Ors [2018] EWHC 385 (Comms) the English Commercial Court (the Court) considered the difficulties which may be encountered in trying to serve on a State. … Continue reading

Leave a Comment

Filed under Advice on State Contracts and Disputes, Enforcement, Privileges and immunities, Sovereign Immunity/State Immunity, State Immunity

UK Supreme Court confirms the limited scope of state and diplomatic immunity from employment claims: Benkharbouche and Reyes

In two judgments handed down on 18 October 2017, the Supreme Court (the “Court”) has allowed certain employment claims made by foreign nationals employed as domestic workers at the embassies of foreign states and a diplomat’s residence to proceed despite … Continue reading

Leave a Comment

Filed under Business & Human Rights, EU, EU Law, Immunity, International Human Rights, Sovereign Immunity/State Immunity, State Immunity, UK

A law on immunity from enforcement in France

The 'Law on Transparency, Anti-corruption Measures and the Modernisation of the Economy' presented by Michel Sapin, Minister for the Economy and Finance, to the Council of Ministers on 30 March 2016, known as the « Sapin II » law, has … Continue reading

Leave a Comment

Filed under France, Immunity, Sovereign Immunity/State Immunity

AIPN EA CHAPTER EVENT: NEGOTIATING STATE IMMUNITY ISSUES IN INTERNATIONAL ENERGY CONTRACTS – LAW & PRACTICE

The immunity of states and their assets from the reach of national courts is an area of law with considerable practical implications for both private and state owned entities entering into international energy contracts. In this panel discussion, the speakers … Continue reading

Leave a Comment

Filed under Advice on State Contracts and Disputes, News, Public International Law, Sovereign Immunity/State Immunity

High Court rules that the principle of non-justiciability, unlike state immunity, cannot be waived

In a recent judgment of 21 June 2016 on a number of summary judgment applications in the case of High Commissioner for Pakistan in the United Kingdom ("Pakistan") v National Westminster Bank (the "Bank"), the English High Court considered the … Continue reading

Leave a Comment

Filed under Act of State Doctrine, Immunity, non-justiciability, State Immunity, UK

Immunity: US Court of Appeals reverses lower court decision that had denied enforcement of foreign arbitral award

In a recent decision handed down on 31 May 2016, the majority in a United States Court of Appeals sitting in Washington DC reversed a decision by the US District Court that had denied enforcement of an arbitral award against … Continue reading

Leave a Comment

Filed under Award, Immunity, Sovereign Immunity/State Immunity, State Immunity, The Americas

The German Federal Supreme Court dismisses claim by bondholders against Greece, denying jurisdiction on grounds of state immunity

The German Federal Supreme Court (Bundesgerichtshof) recently held that creditors cannot bring claims against the Hellenic Republic before the German courts in the context of Greece's debt restructuring in 2012 , finding that Greece enjoys immunity from jurisdiction before the … Continue reading

Leave a Comment

Filed under Germany, Sovereign Immunity/State Immunity, State Immunity

Clarifying the scope of state and diplomatic immunity under English law- the case of Attiya v Jaber Al Thani

Herbert Smith Freehills Partners Dominic Roughton and Andrew Cannon have given an interview to Lexis Nexis following the English court's decision in Attiya v Jaber Al Thani [2016] EWHC 212 (QB). During the interview Andrew and Dominic consider how the English … Continue reading

Leave a Comment

Filed under Sovereign Immunity/State Immunity, State Immunity

English High Court orders payment of $100m arbitral peremptory order, denying KRG claim to immunity

Summary In its recent judgment of 20 November 2015, the High Court of England and Wales (the "Court") enforced a US$100m peremptory order made in arbitral proceedings against the Kurdistan Regional Government of Iraq. The judgment considers a number of … Continue reading

Leave a Comment

Filed under Europe, Middle East, Sovereign Immunity/State Immunity, State Immunity, UK